0 7 min 2 yrs

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – A Democratic condition lawmaker and a non-revenue team have filed a lawsuit alleging the Florida Division of Health and fitness has violated general public-information legal guidelines by refusing to give in-depth data about the COVID-19 pandemic.

Rep. Carlos Guillermo Smith, D-Orlando, and the Florida Middle for Govt Accountability submitted the lawsuit late Monday in Leon County circuit court, right after the department rebuffed requests for info.

The state till early June posted on its site everyday studies that provided intensive facts about issues this sort of as situations and fatalities, with facts also broken down by county. But Gov. Ron DeSantis’ administration halted the day by day reports in June and shifted to posting weekly facts that is significantly significantly less comprehensive.

[TRENDING: Man killed by gator in Ida floodwaters | Fla. officers shoot, kill woman | Become a News 6 Insider (it’s free!)]


The lawsuit alleges that the Office of Wellbeing and Surgeon General Scott Rivkees, the department’s secretary, have violated community-data regulations at a time when the delta variant of the coronavirus has induced circumstances, hospitalizations and deaths to surge in Florida.

“Due to the really contagious character of COVID-19 and its ‘continuing threat’ to Floridians, documents revealing information and facts about its affect, prevalence and fatality is of clear community value,” the lawsuit mentioned. “Floridians have an quick have to have for accessibility to data about the virus and its effect and spread in particular communities. This information and facts is critical to the capacity of citizens to understand the pitfalls and make informed selections about their lives. The function of this action is to obtain crucial data that the department earlier revealed day by day on its web site so that the public will have expertise of and the capacity to scrutinize their government’s response to the rampaging virus. This is the paramount purpose of open up governing administration legislation.”


Smith submitted a prepared ask for July 23 to the Orange County Health Office for everyday details about COVID-19 circumstances, positivity premiums, hospitalizations, deaths and vaccinations.

Drew Like, legislative director for the Florida Department of Well being, responded Aug. 9 and claimed the information Smith had requested was “considered confidential and exempt from community disclosure” below a condition law and state policies, in accordance to an e-mail from Adore incorporated in the lawsuit.

The Tallahassee-dependent Florida Heart for Government Accountability, which focuses on imposing general public-information guidelines, submitted a request Aug. 16 with the Section of Health and fitness looking for day-to-day COVID-19 data involving July 9 and Aug. 15 for each individual county in the condition. It requested daily situation counts and positivity charges and facts about hospitalizations, deaths and vaccinations.

Kendra Washington, a general public documents manager in the Office of Health’s Business of Typical Counsel, responded Aug. 20 and stated the asked for facts was “considered confidential and exempt from public disclosure” less than state legislation and procedures, according to an e mail from Washington integrated in the lawsuit.


The lawsuit disputed that the requested information are exempt from general public release. The documents do not incorporate data identifying personal sufferers.

“The division earlier launched and posted on a everyday basis the really facts sought by plaintiffs,” the lawsuit mentioned. “Additionally, the section and governor have recognized that the require for the general public to be educated about the virus’ spread is significant to making sure community self-confidence in COVID-19 mitigation strategies.”

Some daily data about Florida, including circumstance figures, fatalities and hospitalizations, are posted online by the federal Facilities for Sickness Command and Prevention and the U.S. Division of Well being and Human Companies. But that information does not provide the identical thorough knowledge that the Florida Office of Wellness presented just before scaling again to weekly studies.

In June, DeSantis spokeswoman Christina Pushaw advised The Information Service of Florida that there wasn’t a want to carry on publishing every day stories. At the time, Florida had found a drop in cases, with the delta-fueled surge hitting the point out in July.


“COVID-19 situations have appreciably diminished in excess of the past 12 months as we have a considerably less than 5% positivity price, and our point out is returning to usual, with vaccines broadly readily available through Florida,” Pushaw mentioned in a June electronic mail.

Condition Agent Carlos Guillermo Smith spoke with Information 6 on Tuesday, describing the drive at the rear of his lawsuit in opposition to the state concerning COVID-19 hospitalization data.

Smith said other regional leaders do not have entry to pediatric hospitalization figures in the county. He claimed that data was out there to the general public, prior to June.

“It’s tricky to overcome a issue when you don’t have authentic-time information and facts about the problem.” Guillermo Smith reported. “We had been not inquiring for patient names or social safety numbers. We are practically just inquiring for uncooked facts and quantities as it relates to area covid 19 traits, instances, hospitalizations and fatalities.”

The lawsuit against the Florida Division of Health was submitted together with The Florida Center for Govt Accountability, which also phone calls for the point out to make their COVID-19 online dashboard readily available to the public day-to-day with the facts.


“There is nowhere for you to go to come across that facts. It’s not in the weekly report. It’s not on the CDC’s day by day reporting web page and the actuality is, we employed to have that details,” Guillermo Smith claimed.

The point out is presently releasing COVID-19 info on a weekly foundation, which is considerably extra minimal than information introduced by the condition in the course of other peaks of the pandemic.